It focuses particularly on hospitals within the healthcare system. Adaptive management, natural resource management, environmental management, catchment management introduction adaptive management of natural resources has been my research focus for the past six or so years, so i have been asked to provide some context for other presentations at this conference which deal with adaptive management. Pdf adaptive comanagement for socialecological complexity. Adaptive comanagement for climate change adaptation mdpi. Pdf adaptive comanagement and the paradox of learning. Research and adaptive management at bunchgrass ridge. Analysis of barriers and opportunities, with comparisons to paraty brazil by micaela trimble nunez a thesis submitted to the faculty of graduate studies of the university of manitoba in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of doctor of philosophy. The study of complex adaptive systems, has come to be seen as a scientific frontier, and an increasing ability to interact systematically with highly complex systems that transcend separate disciplines will have a profound affect on future science, engineering and industry as well as in the management of our planets resources emmott. This paper considers the potential of a governmentled initiative designed to build capacity for adaptive collaborative management. Weinstein a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of doctor of philosophy biology in the university of michigan 2009 doctoral committee. These findings, as well as the multilevel conception of social capital, represent contributions to adaptive comanagement theory.
Theory, concepts, and management institutions 1 introduction a common feature of contemporary natural resource management issues is the underlying uncertainty regarding both cause what causal factors account for the problem. One emerging approach aimed at addressing these dilemmas is adaptive comanagement. Towards adaptive comanagement of artisanal fisheries in coastal. Brs offer a unique opportunity to examine these relationships because they aim to foster more adaptive and collaborative forms of management, i. Figure 1in the northwest forest plan, the diminishing extent of oldgrowth forests in the region has raised concerns whether these forests can be sustained and restored. Participatory evaluation could play a role in embedding monitoring and evaluation more strongly, but there is very little empirical research about its.
System and algorithm codesign mu li february 2017 school of computer science carnegie mellon university pittsburgh, pa 152 thesis committee. Positive stakeholders perceptions suggested that comanagement can serve as a platform from which geospatial tools can be implemented to help achieve successful fisheries management. Despite the growing interest in adaptive co management, little is known about processes useful for catalyzing adaptive co management arrangements. Based on those finding, the thesis argues an application of adaptive co management, which is seen to most contribute to socialecological resilience building in. A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of. The actions of organizations are dependent on and limited by how the other actors of the network act and vice versa montalvo et al. Assistive technology for children with disabilities assistive technology for children with disabilities contributors. Scaling distributed machine learning with system and. Constraints on the use of adaptive management in new zealand. Facilitating transitions towards adaptive governance and. In this dissertation, communities are conceived as spatially defined units, including. The number of occurrences per item ranged from a minimum of zero to a maximum of 358 in a doctoral dissertation. Standard operating procedures sops guide emergency responders in a crisis, providing predetermined steps to manage anticipated events.
Images from recent evolo competitions that propose adaptive approaches to tall buildings. In practice these two approaches frequently blend into adaptive comanagement when successive cycles of participation, learning and doing occur. The concept acm has arisen to support the more loose, unpredictable and knowledge intensive processes. Adaptive co management is not only a timely book but also a useful concept for resource governance in a world marked by rapid socioecological change. Adaptive comanagement is a distinct approach within this tradition that encourages flexibility and. Adaptive leadership and interorganizational creativity in.
This paper examines the development of adaptive management in new zealands resource management case law. Adaptive comanagement is an approach that advocates for collaboration and learning in support of environmental management armitage, 2007. Based on those finding, the thesis argues an application of adaptive co management, which is seen to most contribute to socialecological resilience building in the context. Anna burlyaevanorman, shelly chadha, chris cormency, alexandre cote, amy farkas, silvio mariotti, zafar. It will be of interest to researchers, environmental practitioners, policymakers, and students in fields across the political and environmental spectrum.
The concept of thriving is drawn from evolutionary biology, in which a successful adaptation has three. Adaptive leadership is crucial for cocreation of emergent learning and creativity desai, 2010. Although adaptive comanagement is distinct from either approach, the presence of existing models in this lineage provides a logical starting point to begin gathering insights. This thesis provides a case study of the implementation of adaptive co management acm in the australian protected area management context.
Through collaborative monitoring and case study comparison, this thesis explores conceptual and methodological approaches to monitoring transitions toward adaptive comanagement. Starting in 1999, the adaptive learning projects have developed, tested and evaluated the approach in a range of resource systems and some of the lessons learnt are. Phd thesis, uq business school, the university of queensland. Adaptive comanagement has its foundations in the convergence of two independently evolved concepts, adaptive management and comanagement. Adaptive co management thesis proposal i help to study. All the actors of value networks are interdependent. Adaptive management am emerged in the literature in the mid1970s in response both to a realization of the extent of uncertainty involved in management, and a frustration with attempts to use modelling to integrate knowledge and make predictions. Pages 23 in northwest oregon ecology group newsletter ver. Participatory evaluation for adaptive comanagement of social. This section highlights the theoretical contributions of this paper and the current state of knowledge in the field. Pdf building trust through collaboration, institutional development, and social learning enhances efforts to foster ecosystem management and resolve. In particular, this paper investigates a supreme court decision sustain our sounds inc v king salmon new zealand co ltd, which established a set of criteria for implementing adaptive management through new zealands resource management act.
Through collaborative monitoring and case study comparison, this thesis explores conceptual and methodological approaches to monitoring transitions toward adaptive co management. Emergent constraints and their adaptive consequences by bret s. Adaptive architecture american author, marine biologist and conservationist, rachel carson stated the control of nature is a phrase conceived in arrogance, born of. Although monitoring and evaluation are integral components of adaptive comanagement, they are sometimes weakly incorporated.
This thesis approaches decision making in the healthcare system through a systems lens. Apr 25, 2015 adaptive co management has its foundations in the convergence of two independently evolved concepts, adaptive management and co management. Adaptive comanagement is a governance approach gaining. In the following sections, i examine the literature on comanagement in order to identify. For decades, leaders in environmental governance have been directing the attention of their peers towards comanagement frameworks. Adaptive co management is a distinct approach within this tradition that encourages flexibility and adaptability. Towards adaptive comanagement of artisanal fisheries in. Understanding the complexity of economic, ecological, and. The policy is implemented by a police officer who stops the speeding driver. Master thesis koen strijbosch adaptive case management public version 1. Such a model of adaptive co management could be established based intensively on collaboration and trust building between and among, at first, park. Adaptive comanagement in developing world contexts. Adaptive comanagement acm is defined as forging links both horizontal and vertical for shared learningbydoing between various actors, over a medium to long time horizon plummer et al.
These participatory approaches to land management connect local communities and governments through powersharing, and enhanced stakeholder engagement. Adaptive co management has its foundations in the convergence of two independently evolved concepts, adaptive management and co management. Although adaptive co management is distinct from either approach, the presence of existing models in this lineage provides a logical starting point to begin gathering insights. I certify that the present work is original, that all material in this thesis that is not my. Diverse ecological epistemologies and adaptive comanagement. Penalties are defined by government policy and lawmakers for drivers who exceed the speed limit.
Becoming an adaptive leader based on the work of ronald heifetz and marty linsky daptive leadership is the activity of mobilizing people to tackle tough challenges and thrive. Towards adaptive comanagement of artisanal fisheries in coastal uruguay. Adaptive comanagement is not only a timely book but also a useful concept for resource governance in a world marked by rapid socioecological change. In the paper was assigned a chapter to each stage of the strategic management. Its origin can be traced back to ideas of scientific management pioneered by frederick taylor in the early 1900s 2,3.
This paper examines relationships among perceived processes and outcomes in four unesco biosphere reserves brs. The introductory remarks of this paper assert that adaptive comanagement is the outcome of merging comanagement and adaptive management. The introductory remarks of this paper assert that adaptive co management is the outcome of merging co management and adaptive management. Adaptive standard operating procedures for complex disasters. In practice these two approaches frequently blend into adaptive comanagement when successive cycles of. Various perspectives on adaptive management are rooted in parallel concepts. Adaptive comanagement and its relationship to environmental. From conventional fisheries management to adaptive comanagement. In practice these two approaches frequently blend into adaptive co management when successive cycles of participation, learning and doing occur. Adaptive management, a concept first articulated by holling 1978, has been used in natural resource contexts such as fisheries management halbert 1993 and balancing salmon restoration with energy conservation lee 1993.
Assistive technology for children with disabilities. Graduate thesis or dissertation exploring pathways to. The first seven chapters of this doctoral thesis are allocated literature study. Such a model of adaptive comanagement could be established based intensively on collaboration and trust building between and among, at first, park. These comanagement councils provide a space to increase awareness, improve communication, and facilitate both training and education. Manley, 1989 a properly organized logistics contains. Adaptive management for water resources project planning. This method draws explicit attention to the learning experiential and experimental and collaboration vertical and horizontal functions necessary to improve our understanding of, and ability to respond to. Based on those finding, the thesis argues an application of adaptive comanagement, which is seen to most contribute to socialecological resilience building in the context. Although monitoring and evaluation are integral components of adaptive co management, they are sometimes weakly incorporated. This manuscriptstyle thesis approaches the concepts of risk, uncertainty, and the permitting process for mre from three distinct angles. In practice these two approaches frequently blend into. For decades, leaders in environmental governance have been directing the attention of their peers towards co management frameworks.
Adaptive comanagement for socialecological complexity article pdf available in frontiers in ecology and the environment 7. In so doing, a number of knowledge gaps are addressed. Multilevel governance through adaptive comanagement. Johan borg, rosangela bermanbieler, chapal khasnabis, gopal mitra, william n myhill, and deepti samant raja. The research findings reveal that the flood management and adaptation practices, through the deltas opening. Adaptive comanagement as an approach to tourism destination. The purpose of this study was to create a comprehensive framework for decision making in healthcare systems. Adaptive co management and world heritage management. Adaptive management is a systematic approach for improving resource management by learning from management outcomes 1. This framework is informed by qualitativeoriented synthesisbased methodologies in social sciences petticrew and roberts, 2006, carter and little, 2007, crowther and cook, 2007, barnettpage and thomas, 2009, snilstveit et al. Adaptive comanagement is defined as a process by which institutional arrangements and ecological knowledge are tested and revised in a dynamic, ongoing, selforganized process of learningbydoing berkes 2004. These transformational cycles take place in nested sets at scales ranging from a leaf to the biosphere over periods from days to geologic. Adaptive comanagement as an approach to tourism destination governance a.
516 1506 282 1513 1131 863 1140 625 1442 1023 1371 823 460 1065 1010 512 731 852 1064 1348 1362 1335 701 1402 1028 273 737 1567 1581 386 818 984 973 642 852 1288 528 1493 310 437 137 284 284 1004 1257 494